The Meaning of Rejection

  • By: Jessica Faust | Date: Mar 12 2019

Authors often find frustration with the vagueness of rejection letters. Understandably they would like to know exactly why an agent is rejecting their work and hearing, “it’s not right for me,” just isn’t clear enough.

I get it and I hear you. But the truth is that a lot of the queries and submissions I reject are just because they weren’t right for me. Think of an agent as a reader in a bookstore. We are looking for something to add to our to-be-read pile or, in an agent’s case, our to-be-represented pile. What we want is something that excites us and keeps us reading past our subway stop.

So when a reader comments on my Query Mistakes blog post with this question I’m saddened.

I equate rejection with either failure on the one hand or the final word on the fact that my writing isn’t good enough on the other. Can you comment? What do rejection letters really mean? (Aside from the obvious: your writing is atrocious. Please never approach me again. Ever.)

Because here is the thing. Rejection is not a failure. Not in the least. A rejection shows that you are putting yourself and your work out there. That you are taking the next steps in your career. That in itself is a win for me.

What a rejection means is your book isn’t something that grabbed the attention of that agent. Unless you do get specific feedback, which will come further in your career I promise, you can’t search for meanings in rejection. Sure I could reject your query because of the writing, but if I don’t say that specifically you can’t put those words in my mouth.

I resent the idea that I would ever suggest an author not approach me again. Many of my own clients were signed after previously receiving rejections. In fact, I encourage authors to keep the queries coming, even after rejection. There’s nothing that makes me happier than knowing authors want to work with me and the best way to show that is by filling up my Query Manager.

Getting published takes persistence and perseverance as much as it takes a good book.

13 responses to “The Meaning of Rejection”

  1. Avatar Debra A Nasser says:

    Hi Jessica,
    I have queried you before. Although I have totally fell in love with my own debut novel (after query rejections and several editing and re- editingoverhauls), I am now ready to query you once again with a totallynew completed project. See you soon

    • Avatar rafay says:

      The meaning of rejection is not only the way that its the end or failure. Its about a new beginning of cheap sofa set in karachi, as author truly saying about the issues and the letters of rejection he received.

  2. Great post! It’s rare for an agency to be supportive and encouraging to all writers – but that’s why I and other writers I know like and admire Bookends.

  3. Avatar Lee Jackson says:

    If I’ve made significant changes to my book, especially the first 10 pages, and it’s been, say, 3 years since I’ve queried said book, would it be considered wrong if I re-queried that book to the same agents who originally turned it down?

  4. Avatar Martha says:

    Great post. And good reminders.

  5. Hi, I’ve few questions to ask can you please explain to me if my rejection for book writing with no reason just little bit mistake and client didn’t ask me to do some changes so what should i do?

  6. Avatar Todd says:

    I’m sure agents get all sorts of reactions from people they reject. We appreciate all that you do. I think some people’s frustration stems from the fact they don’t get any reason for the rejection other than a form email. it’s not reasonable to expect an agent to personally respond to the hundreds of queries they receive each week. But for agents who ask authors to send a query and sample chapters, it would be very helpful to know if the rejection is based solely on the query (didn’t grab me) or if the agent actually read a few pages and decided it wasn’t for them.

  7. Avatar AJ Blythe says:

    Facing rejection is hard. No-one is immune to some level of hurt when they receive a rejection. I think the important thing to remember it isn’t you who is being rejected, but your book. I think too many writers take rejection personally, and that isn’t what it is.

  8. Avatar Laura W-A says:

    I appreciate this post. I’m hoping mswl trends come in waves – only a few agents and small presses want Greek gods right now, but they did a few years ago. Maybe they will again, and until then I have witches and space ships and mysteries I can write…

  9. Avatar Laura W-A says:

    Is it ever simply a matter of the subject (such as Greek gods) being “tired,” and even agents who wanted them with grabby hands a couple of years ago want nothing to do with them? Trends cycle around, right? So if I write other things for a while, at some point what I *want* to write might be salable?

  10. Avatar Laura W-A says:

    And apparently I need to never comment in the middle of the night, since I forgot I did so five days after the first time… oops.

  11. The rejection might be possible for many reasons, sometimes the low-quality work causes the rejection. If students are taking the assignment assistance, they check the expertise and the quality of assignments they got.

  12. Rejection depend on works mostly writers take ideas on internet and it’s looks like copied from someone else use your own wording