Series Authors Should Stop Writing the Sequel

  • By: Jessica Faust | Date: May 22 2017

When an author envisions a book as part of a series it’s natural to finish the first book and dive right into writing the second book, or the sequel. Let me explain why I don’t think this is an effective business plan.

No matter how you look at it, a sequel is dependent on the first book. It’s why you call it a sequel or why you refer to it as the second book in the series. By writing the sequel before you’ve sold the first book you’ve potentially limited yourself from selling two books, especially if rejections on the first book are based on the idea or the hook and not the writing. A second book with the same hook isn’t likely to sell any better.

My suggestion is instead of focusing on the series you’ve planned, create another series. Should you sell that first book, which I certainly hope you do, it will be easy to circle back and continue writing the series. If you don’t sell it, or it takes a super long time, you now have something fresh and new to start submitting instead of struggling with who to submit the sequel to after they’ve already rejected the first book.

10 responses to “Series Authors Should Stop Writing the Sequel”

  1. This would be useful information for agents and editors to share at RWA conferences.

    • Jessica Faust Jessica Faust says:

      I know we share it quite a bit and I’ve been saying this for years on panels and in workshops.

  2. Avatar Ana Calin says:

    Missed you, Jessica! Totally with you! Not a fan of series with same characters (same h/h pair) anyway, but maybe they’ll listen to YOU until I become a big name out there, too, and they listen to me as well 🙂 Hugs!

  3. This jolts my creative juices. Thank you!

    Now…which series to go with? Decisions, decisions.

  4. Avatar AJ Blythe says:

    Had this one from previous posts. Which is why I am finishing my current first-in-series wip and plotting the first in another.

  5. Avatar Kate Fellowes says:

    I’m glad I read this now, when I’ve been brainstorming ideas for book 2 while looking for an agent with book 1 in my cozy series. Thanks for posting it.

  6. Good advice. Good game plan.

  7. […] https://bookendsliterary.com/series-authors-should-stop-writing-the-sequel/ Are you writing the second or third or more in a series? Unless your Indie publishing, here’s why you should consider waiting. I’ve done this many times and perhaps that’s something I need to hold back on in the future until the time’s right. […]

  8. This week in books 5/26/17 says:

    […] Sometimes authors get so wrapped up in a long story arc they can’t imagine their trilogy or seventeen book series happening any other way. They plow forward writing two or three books (or one REALLY long novel) before they try to publish, envisioning a publisher snatching up all three books at once. Here’s why agent Jessica Faust thinks that’s a bad business decision. […]

  9. […] Sometimes authors get so wrapped up in a long story arc they can’t imagine their trilogy or seventeen book series happening any other way. They plow forward writing two or three books (or one REALLY long novel) before they try to publish, envisioning a publisher snatching up all three books at once. Here’s why agent Jessica Faust thinks that’s a bad business decision. […]